Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Angsana Anderson's avatar

(2) The reported 11.5% FCF yield overstates Kimly’s true cash generation.

11.5% is calculated from SGD 55 mn of FCF.

But additions to right-of-use (ROU) assets have not been deducted from SGD 55 mn.

For a lease-heavy operator like Kimly, those ROU additions are capex and should be deducted from operating cash flow when estimating FCF.

Additions to ROU represent the cost of acquiring operating rights over coffee shop sites.

However, the cash flow statement fails to show them as capex because it is immediately offset by financing inflow from lease liabilities.

"A lease is an investing transaction, where a company buys a fixed asset, and a financing transaction, where the company raises debt.”

Once the adjustment is made, true FCF yield likely falls to ~2% in FY2025.

Angsana Anderson's avatar

The SEA Analyst,

(1) What is your assessment of management?

Some time ago, I was also interested in Kimly Limited (1D0; KMLY SP).

But I passed after this news: "Ex-chairman, director of coffee shop chain Kimly fined for not disclosing stake in acquisition of company" [1]

DPP Suhas Malhotra said the case involves "an intentional and blatant refusal to comply with the disclosure obligations which apply to all publicly listed companies in Singapore".

On Lim's conduct, Mr Malhotra said this was "an unabashed choice by Lim to not disclose his interest in ASC, in contravention of the law".

"That the executive chairman of a public company can treat his company's obligations in such a cavalier manner is troubling, to say the least," he said.

[1] https://www.channelnewsasia.com/singapore/kimly-ex-chairman-director-fined-not-disclosing-stake-coffee-shop-chain-2501866

4 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?